You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Describe the bug
When calling addScopes, the check against the existing granted scopes doesn't normalize the names. If the core scopes are passed in using their short names (email, openid, profile), the SDK will prompt unnecessarily, because the granted scopes appear to use the v2 names.
Obviously this can be easily worked around from the client side by not making that call in the first place, but it creates some unexpected complexity in the Flutter wrapper (see flutter/flutter#184872), which has to bridge across the iOS, Android, and Web sign in APIs (which are all quite different). We can work around it at the wrapper level, but it would be nice if the SDK handled this name mismatch internally.
To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:
Sign in.
Call addScopes:... with [@"email", @"openid", @"profile"] as the scopes.
See a user prompt.
Expected behavior
Receive kGIDSignInErrorCodeScopesAlreadyGranted, since AFAICT signing in grants those scopes automatically, but under different names.
Thanks for bringing this to our attention! You make a great point. I see how this is confusing and can be enhanced.
We'll keep this issue open for now and triage it for our backlog so we can look into adding this in a future release once bandwidth clears up on our end. In the meantime, thanks for finding a workaround on your end!
Activity
brnnmrls commentedon Apr 13, 2026
Thanks for bringing this to our attention! You make a great point. I see how this is confusing and can be enhanced.
We'll keep this issue open for now and triage it for our backlog so we can look into adding this in a future release once bandwidth clears up on our end. In the meantime, thanks for finding a workaround on your end!